Warning: SPOILERS ahead for Sunrise on the Reaping by Suzanne Collins.

The Hunger Gamesfranchise has no shortage of disturbing moments, butSunrise on the Reaping’s most gruesome death makes aCatching Firecharacter’s backstory far more tragic. As Haymitch’s prequel novel coversthe 50th Hunger Games tournament— during which double the number of tributes are reaped from each district — there are even moredeaths inSunrise on the Reapingthan there are in Katniss Everdeen’s Games. Some of these are more memorable than others, and the worst of them will remain with readers long after they close the book.

Jeffrey Wright as Beetee in The Hunger Games: Catching Fire.

This is becauseSunrise on the Reaping’s most brutal end affects Haymitch, butit’s even more devastating for a prominent character from Katniss' story. It will make readers feel differently when revisitingCatching FireandMockingjay,and it offers further insight into their role in the rebellion against the Capitol. Beetee isn’t vocal about his motivations or past when he meets Katniss and Peeta, but thanks to his own time in the arena, Haymitch knows all about them. And afterSunrise on the Reaping’s ending, they both have something in common: losing loved ones to the Capitol in truly heinous ways.

Sunrise On The Reaping Gives Beetee A Son & A Much More Tragic Backstory

Ampert’s Introduction Sets Him Up For Tragedy On Par With Haymitch’s

Sunrise on the Reapingreveals that Beetee has a family, and more importantly, a 12-year-old son who participates in Haymitch’s Hunger Games. Ampert is forced into the second Quarter Quell as a punishment for Beetee, who is caught messing with the Capitol’s communication systems. President Snow uses Beetee’s loved ones against him, just as he does with Haymitch. Andthe worst part of the whole situation is that Beetee is forced to act as a mentor for his child, knowing that he’s likely sending him to his death.

Every Returning Hunger Games Character In Sunrise On The Reaping

Sunrise on the Reaping returns readers to the world of Panem, and Haymitch’s Hunger Games prequel features many familiar faces within its pages.

Despite Beetee’s and Ampert’s acceptance of their situation,the latter adds a devastating layer to Beetee’sHunger Gamesstory from the moment he’s introduced. After all, readers know that Haymitch wins the second Quarter Quell, so there’s no way Ampert is walking out of the arena. And while it’s admirable that Beetee and Ampert attempt to use their punishment to push back against the Capitol, it results in a terrible end for Beetee’s son. It will leave readers feeling as bad for him as they do for Haymitch, and that’s saying something.

President Snow and Haymitch Abernathy from The Hunger Games standing in front of the cover of Sunrise on the Reaping

Ampert’s Death Is One Of The Most Gruesome In The Entire Hunger Games Franchise

It’s Up There With Cato’s & Finnick’s

After Haymitch and Ampert attempt to break the arena using Beetee’s plan, Ampert is targeted and killed.The Capitol sends muttations after him, and Haymitch notes that they seem specifically programmed to focus on Beetee’s son and no one else. So, Haymitch is forced to watch as golden squirrel mutts tear Ampert apart, leaving nothing but a skeleton when they’re finished. It’s easily one of the franchise’s most gruesome deaths, alongside Cato’s at theend ofThe Hunger Gamesand Finnick’s inMockingjay.

The image of Ampert’s skeleton is harrowing, and it’s even more devastating to realize that Beetee will be forced to see it.

The cover of The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping with a purple background, red dots, and fire on the edges

The image of Ampert’s skeleton is harrowing, and it’s even more devastating to realize that Beetee will be forced to see it. It’s a truly terrible way for his son to die, and Haymitch’s thought that “somewhere, Beetee’s heart breaks into fragments so small it can never be repaired” makes this moment all the more gut-wrenching. Beetee doesn’t appear to be a terribly emotional character in the originalHunger Gamestrilogy, butSunrise on the Reaping’s brutal treatment of Ampert makes it easier to understand and empathize with him.

Sunrise On The Reaping’s Beetee Story Perfectly Sets Up His Catching Fire Role

Adding this tragic layer of depth to Beetee’s backstory makes sense of his role inCatching FireandMockingjay, explaining why he’s so invested in Panem’s rebellion. While most people in the districts have good reason to revolt against the Capitol,Sunrise on the Reapingoffers detailed explanations for why several of the tributes called for the 75th Hunger Games are so eager to help Katniss and Peeta.One could hardly blame Beetee for wanting justice after what happened to Ampert, and it’s a testament to his character that he votes against Coin’s plan at the end ofMockingjay.

Why President Snow Really Lets Haymitch Live In The Hunger Games: Sunrise On The Reaping

Leaving Haymitch alive after Sunrise on the Reaping seems counterproductive, but President Snow’s actions after the 50th Hunger Games make sense.

The prequel novel also reveals that Beetee and his wife have another child on the way, and we see no sign of Beetee’s family during Katniss' story. While Beetee’s second child would be in their 20s by the timeThe Hunger Gamesbegins, it’s very possible that Snow targets the rest of his family after Ampert. This gives Beetee even more incentive to betray the Capitol years afterSunrise on the Reaping,and it makes him one of the most tragic figures to appear in the original books.

President Snow looking angry and Haymitch Abernathy smirking with Sunrise on the Reaping in the middle

Sunrise on the Reaping Suzanne Collins Novel Cover