American Idoljudge Carrie Underwood recently posted a gorgeous selfie which really showed off her natural beauty, and although the camera loves the talented singer (whose post-AIcareer has been so successful and inspiring), I’m not sure that she’s the right choice for the popular ABC series. WhileCarrie’s been blessed with so many attributesthat she’s akin to a modern-day Disney princess, including beauty, talent and goodness,her sweetness might actually put her at a disadvantage.
Since she’s so caring, Carrie feels everything. Her strong empathy can make it difficult for her to detach while she’s assessing contestants. However, it’s also her superpower. If she couldn’t emotionally connect with others while she’s singing or doing meet-and-greets, she might not be where she is today. Her sensitivity is a double-edged sword. One of ScreenRant’s writers,Lorianne Palinkas, met Carrie in Trenton, New Jersey, and had a wonderful experience. Off-screen, Carrie’s just as kind and gracious as you might imagine.
Carrie’s Selfie Shows A Radiant Woman With Kind Eyes
Carrie Is A Superstar Who Deserves Her Fame
Carrierelaxes in the Instagram post shown above, getting ready to watch a newAmerican Idolepisode. She’s got a"boule"and"vino,“and while she may not be truly makeup-free,she’s pretty much in her natural state. This woman doesn’t need a lot of makeup to look good - no woman does. She’s beautiful just as she is, and appears to be totally content. While Carrie’s just instantly likable, thanks to her kind eyes and sweet smile, what makes anAmerican Idoleffective isn’t always an “America’s Sweetheart” image.
Is Carrie Too Sensitive To Be A Great American Idol Judge?
She May Care Too Much
Carrie grew up on a farm, and by her mid-teens, she’d already been discovered. She was offered a recording contract, and her life would have been very different if that deal didn’t fall through. However, there was a management shakeup, which meant that she wasn’t formally signed to the record label.
That’s why Carrie was a free agent when she decided to try her luck onAmerican Idolseason 4. That twist of fate led to the type of “skyrocketing” career trajectory that some of the greats experience. Like Elvis Presley, Carrie burrowed her way right into the heart of America.
Carrie’s a superstar. She’s not in the lower echelons of fame.She’s right on top, and her star quality’s so extreme that it’s hard to look at anyone else when she’s onscreen.For this reason, as well as Carrie’s acute sensitivity, she may be a dream girl, but not an idealAmerican Idoljudge.
20 Best Reality TV Shows Right Now
Reality TV is more popular than ever. With so many to choose from, here are some of the best reality TV shows to stream or watch right now.
Carrie’s Barbie-perfect beauty and “voice from God” aren’t all that she’s got going for her. There’s real charisma there - something mysterious that’s hard to quantify. Call it magic - it’s a gift that isn’t given to everyone. As well, Carrie is able to feel her fans' feelings - their joy, their pain, their nerves.
She uses her empathy to understand her audience and give them what they want.
However, the point ofAmerican Idolis to showcase new singers whowant to be like Carrie. With her onscreen, she risks overshadowing them each and every time. Yes, she cares about them, but sometimes she may overstep because she does. InAmerican Idolseason 23, Carrie told singer Breanna Nix not to describe herself as"just a stay-at-home mom.”
Breanna had called herself that, but maybe Carrie needs to dial down the empathy, and avoid telling contestants what to say.
Carrie meant well as she usually does. She wanted Breanna to understand the value of taking care of a child at home. It’s true that this is hard work that’s really important. That was the point Carrie was making. However, Breanna is a grown woman - she’s a mom. If she wants to describe herself a certain way, that’s up to her.
This is an example ofhow Carrie’s sensitivity can backfire. With the very best intentions, she can still make mistakes. Her sensitive approach to judging may also end up hurting contestants because they instantly bond with her. If she has to criticize, it could hurt them more than it would coming from a meaner judge.
Carrie’s Not A Mean Judge Like Simon Cowell Was
However, Her Critiques May Hurt More
Yes, a cutting performance review from acruelAmerican Idolicon like Simon Cowell, who admittedly usually told the truth about contestants' abilities, but with an acerbic touch, might not have the same sting. People expect Simon to turn on them. They expect to be torn apart. They hope for more, but brace themselves.
Carrie is someone that a lot of people love, including contestants. She’s like a ray of sunshine - something warm and golden that they can bask in.However, her job is to decide who’s got it and who doesn’t.When Carrie critiques, it may be very painful for the singers, who probably still love her no matter what.
American Idolasks a lot of judges. They need to harden their hearts so they can make the best decisions. While they don’t hold all the power, they definitely have a lot of clout. They influence the people who vote at home. WIth Carrie, the jury’s still out. She may end up being a legendary judge, but the red flags discussed here suggest that things could go awry.
